Easter Eggs in Mitski’s 'Where’s My Phone?' Video — Shirley Jackson References You Missed

Hook: You missed details — we found them

If you hit play on Mitski's "Where's My Phone?" and felt like you blinked through a dozen deliberate, literary micro-moments — welcome. You're not alone. Fans who crave episode-level breakdowns, frame-by-frame spoils, and a single place to nerd out about visual callbacks have been asking: what exactly in this video is Shirley Jackson, and what is Mitski (and director Noel Paul) doing with it?

This is a spoiler-friendly visual scavenger hunt: part close-reading, part watch-party checklist. We'll point out specific frames, props, and directorial choices that nod to We Have Always Lived in the Castle and general Shirley Jackson imagery — then give you the tools to continue the hunt live, create shareable clips, and build a community doc of finds. Consider this your field guide for decoding the video in 4K, slow-motion, and, crucially, in public.

Why this matters now (2026 context)

By early 2026 the pop-music ecosystem has doubled down on layered, intertextual music videos. Late 2025 saw a wave of music promos that adapted literary works or quoted them visually — a trend driven by streaming platforms offering higher-resolution premieres and by fans wanting more than 30-second TikTok snippets. Mitski's new album announcement and the release of "Where's My Phone?" were explicitly linked to Shirley Jackson's We Have Always Lived in the Castle — a fact reported in Variety on Jan. 16, 2026 and repeated across music press.

“The video, directed by Noel Paul, is based on Shirley Jackson’s novel, We Have Always Lived in the Castle.” — Variety, Jan 16, 2026

That confirmation gives us license to hunt. In 2026, visual analysis lives in the second-screen era: fans watch on a main screen, frame-grab on a phone, and share in Discord minutes later. Directors like Noel Paul are often collaborating with cinematographers and production designers to embed literary Easter eggs that reward repeat views and community sleuthing. This article gives you the checklist and the methodology — the stuff that actually solves the pain point of fragmented fan discovery.

Top-level takeaways (so you know what to look for)

• Motifs to watch: domestic objects (silverware, tea sets), isolation framing (rooms that feel like cages), ritual objects (buttons, coins, talismans), and the recurring use of reflective surfaces (mirrors, windows).
• Directorial fingerprints: static wide shots that mimic novelistic tableaux, close-up detail shots that feel like Merricat’s rituals, and color palettes skewed toward washed pastels punctured by black.
• Where to pause: opening establishing shot, first table scene, the reflective close-up, and the walk-through that shows the outside world vs. the house world.

Visual scavenger hunt: frame-by-frame clues and what they mean

Below is a guided walkthrough you can use whether you’re watching in the YouTube app, a desktop browser, or in a physical watch party. I’ll note the moment (relative to the song's structure — intro, verse, chorus, bridge) and describe what to freeze on. Each entry includes the prop/shot, the likely Shirley Jackson echo, and a quick line on how to clip or share it for fans.

1) Opening tableau — the house-as-protagonist

What to freeze: the first wide shot after the title card, where architecture and negative space dominate.

Why it matters: In We Have Always Lived in the Castle, the house itself is a character: closed, protective, and claustrophobic. Directors often cue the novel by making the house the opening subject, not the singer. Look for tight framing on windowpanes, slightly askew shutters, or a porch that reads like a threshold between safety and hostility.

Clip tip: Export a 3–5 second GIF of the establishing shot and post it with the hashtag #MitskiEasterEgg to seed community discussion on whether the house was built to mirror Merricat’s perspective.

2) The dining table and silverware motif

What to freeze: any medium-close of Mitski's hands at a table, especially shots emphasizing spoons, knives, or a tea set.

Why it matters: Shirley Jackson's novel famously hinges on poisoning and the social rituals of dining — silverware becomes evidence and indictment in the story. Directors nod to that by foregrounding utensils or showing them in slow motion, sometimes catching light off a blade to make it feel accusatory.

Clip tip: Use frame-by-frame (keyboard arrow keys in most players) to find the moment the light 'glances' off metal. That is a deliberate cue; make a 6-second slo-mo for sharing as a discussion starter.

3) Ritual objects: buttons, coins, and 'protective' trinkets

What to freeze: close-ups of hands burying, hiding, or arranging small objects, or scenes where objects are tucked into books or pockets.

Why it matters: Merricat’s superstition and rituals are central to Jackson’s book. Close-ups on small, mundane talismans replicate that interior life visually — you’re literally being asked to read objects as actions. If the video shows repeated gestures (placing something under a plate, tying ribbon, or arranging stones), treat those as Merricat analogues.

4) Mirrors, reflections, and fractured composition

What to freeze: any shot where Mitski’s face is partially obscured by a window or split by a mirror — or where the camera corrals the frame into symmetrical halves.

Why it matters: The novel’s psychological split — public vs. private, memory vs. reality — is often visualized via reflections. Directors use shards and panes to imply doubling. In Mitski’s video, pay attention to how reflections change between verses; the camera may linger to show an inner life shifting subtly.

5) The outsider crowd / village shots

What to freeze: wide or medium shots that include a group of people outside the home — especially if they are cut off by a fence or window.

Why it matters: Jackson’s villagers are both chorus and antagonist. Filmmakers mimic that social pressure with camera angles that keep the crowd at the margins, sometimes out of focus, always looming. If Mitski’s video frames the outside world as an aggressive blur, that’s a directorial shorthand for the novel’s mob scenes.

6) The cat(s) and animal motifs

What to freeze: any moment with an animal, particularly a cat, in lap or wandering through a room.

Why it matters: Animals in Jackson’s fiction often signify domestic rhythms, uncanny presences, or moral companions. If the video places a cat at the center of a composition, consider it a sensory link to Constance’s caretaking and Merricat’s complicit rituals.

7) Textual props: letters, books, and handwriting

What to freeze: close shots on handwritten notes, books on a shelf, or labels on jars.

Why it matters: Jackson’s narrative is epistolary-adjacent: objects hold memory. Directors nod to this by making sure viewers can read titles or scribbles, often reversing them for subliminal effect. If there's a visible book spine in the exact frame, screenshot it — titles are rarely accidental.

Directorial choices to decode: how Noel Paul translates Jackson visually

Noel Paul’s direction in the video (as credited the week of the single’s release) uses film grammar that parallels Jackson’s text. Here are the recurring choices and what they do:

• Tableau staging — wide, static shots that let sets breathe, mirroring the novel’s slow-burn intimacy.
• Micro-close-ups — sustained focus on hands and objects to externalize inner ritual.
• Muted palette with blackout punctuation — pastels and faded color to suggest faded gentility and the black clothing of mourning or guilt.
• Rhythmic edits — repetition of motifs at chorus returns, turning the song’s hooks into visual refrains, like Merricat's recurring protective gestures.

All of these choices push the video from a simple narrative to an adaptation-in-flavor: it's not a scene-for-scene of Jackson's book but a visual echo chamber that invites viewers to map the novel’s moods onto Mitski’s lyrics.

Practical, actionable advice: how to host your own 2026-style scavenger hunt

If you want to run a watch party or build a community resource, follow this step-by-step plan. These steps are optimized for 2026 fan behavior — multi-platform, shareable, and spoiler-conscious.

1. Prep the room: Pick a streaming source in 4K if possible. Use a second device for real-time clip-capture (phone camera or OBS on desktop).
2. Create a spoiler protocol: In your Discord or watch-party room, make a pinned message that labels channels: #no-spoilers, #timestamps, #full-spoilers. Encourage people to use timestamps when posting findings.
3. Use frame-grab tools: On desktop, VLC and MPV let you step frame-by-frame. Browser extensions like FrameGrabber or the YouTube timestamp-copy feature help create permalinks to frames. In 2026, many streaming platforms include built-in frame-scrubbing with 1-frame precision — use it.
4. Collect and centralize: Open a Google Sheet or Notion page to record timestamps, scene description, and proposed Jackson link. Include a column for fan-supplied GIFs or cropped stills (hosted on an image CDN or Imgur alternative).
5. Verify and cite: If you assert a specific Jackson link (e.g., 'knife as evidence of poisoning'), include a short line quoting the novel or a page reference if possible, or link to a reliable summary for non-readers.
6. Clip & share properly: Keep clips under platform copyright thresholds where possible (15–30 sec) and always credit Mitski, Noel Paul, and the official video account. Use clear spoiler tags when posting to public threads.

Advanced strategies for the obsessed (AI tools, metadata, and preservation)

By 2026 there are tools that make scouring music videos for Easter eggs faster and more defensible. Use them with care.

• Auto-frame annotation: Use machine vision tools (e.g., open-source object detectors) to batch-scan the video for recurring objects — spoons, mirrors, cats — then overlay timestamps into your shared doc. This reduces false negatives.
• Color sampling: Extract color palettes from key frames to show the production design’s intentional palette shifts across the song. This helps prove the 'washed pastels + black' theory.
• Preserve high-res stills: If you’re collecting screenshots for archiving, store lossless PNGs and include metadata: video URL, exact timestamp, and capture tool used. This matters if the video gets geo-restricted or removed.
• Use AI cautiously: AI captioning can help surface on-screen text or handwritten notes. Always cross-check — OCR mistakes still happen with stylized fonts.

How to turn your finds into fan content that lands

Fans want discussion and snackable content. Here’s a cadence to convert discoveries into posts that perform on social platforms in 2026.

1. Micro-threads: Post a 5–7 tweet/X thread that pairs a screenshot with a 1-2 sentence Jackson tie. Keep language direct and link to your timestamped doc.
2. Reels and Shorts: Make 20–30 second breakdowns focusing on a single Easter egg: show the frame, explain the Jackson link, and end with a call-to-action to check your doc for more.
3. Long-form deep dives: Host a 20–30 minute live stream where you do the frame-by-frame with guests (a literary fan and a cinematographer ideally) to increase E-E-A-T.
4. Merch & monetization: If Mitski or the estate releases official merch tied to the video or book, create an annotated shopping post that ties product imagery to specific frames.

Common fan questions — answered

Is the video a literal adaptation of the book?

No. The video is a visual meditation informed by Shirley Jackson’s novel. Think of it as a mood-based adaptation: motifs and emotional beats are borrowed, not a beat-for-beat translation.

Are specific lines in the song quoting Jackson?

Not literally — Mitski’s lyrics remain her own. But the video’s objects and blocking often create an interpretive bridge between the song’s emotional content and Jackson’s themes of isolation, ritual, and suspicion.

How much can we trust visual links?

Directorial choices — costume, prop placement, and repeated motifs — are deliberate. Because the production team credited the novel, it's reasonable to read these as intentional allusions. Still, separate your confirmed facts (credit to Noel Paul, the Variety announcement) from interpretive claims in your fan doc.

Ethics, credit, and attribution

If your scavenger hunt turns into a viral thread or a monetized series of clips, attribute. Always credit Mitski, Noel Paul, the cinematographer (if listed in credits), and the Shirley Jackson estate or the novel’s title when relevant. In 2026, the most respected fan projects are the ones that cite sources, avoid claiming original ownership of official material, and offer proper links to purchase or stream the work.

Final notes: why this kind of analysis matters

We live in a fandom era where a music video isn’t a 3-minute promotional tool — it’s a cultural artifact that fans decode, collect, and archive. Mitski’s "Where’s My Phone?" is an invitation to interpretive play with a literary ancestor. Noel Paul’s direction gives you plenty of crumbs; your job as a fan sleuth is to gather those crumbs responsibly, share them with timestamps, and build a community resource that survives platform churn.

Actionable takeaways — do this next

• Watch the video on a big screen with a second device for frame-grabs.
• Create a shared document (Google Sheets/Notion) with columns for timestamp, frame description, suspected Jackson link, and a GIF or still.
• Host a spoiler-safe watch party: use channels for “no-spoilers” and “full-spoilers” and pin a scavenger-hunt checklist.
• Use AI tools for color sampling and object detection, but always human-verify before posting.
• When posting, always credit Mitski, Noel Paul, and the official video — include a link to the Variety Jan 16, 2026 announcement when referencing the video’s literary basis.

Call to action

Ready to join the scavenger hunt? Start a thread in our Discord or drop your top three timestamped finds in the comments below. We’ll compile the best submissions into a public Notion resource and host a live breakdown with a special guest cinematographer next week — spoiler-safe and fan-first. Tag your clips with #MitskiEasterEgg and #WheresMyPhone so we can find them. Let’s turn fragmented clues into a single, shareable map of Mitski’s Shirley Jackson nods.

See you at the table.

Related Reading

• Secret Lair and Superdrops: How to Snag Fallout and Other Limited MTG Drops Without Paying Panic Prices
• How Retail Convenience Stores Are Shaping Acne Product Access: What the Asda Express Expansion Means for You
• Monetize the Estate: Lessons From Goalhanger for Managing Musician Legacies
• Secret Lair and Crossover Drops: How to Spot Valuable MTG Reprints Before They Pop
• Cosy Shed Hacks: Hot-Water Bottles, Microwavable Pads, and Rechargeable Warmers for Cold Workshops